Securities or Commodities? New Bill Draws a Line for US Digital Asset Regulation

Legislation aims to provide regulatory clarity to attract institutional capital while defining the roles of the SEC and CFTC.

A sweeping bipartisan bill, the "Responsible Financial Innovation Act of 2025," has been introduced, proposing the first comprehensive regulatory framework for digital assets in the United States. The legislation seeks to end years of market uncertainty by drawing distinct jurisdictional lines between the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) and the Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC), a move long demanded by the crypto industry.

At the heart of the bill is a nuanced approach to classifying digital assets. A central tenet is the creation of a new definition for an "ancillary asset"—an intangible asset, including a digital token, that may be part of an investment contract. Crucially, the legislation specifies that the ancillary asset itself is not automatically deemed a security, potentially allowing many tokens to be regulated as commodities by the CFTC, even if they were part of an initial fundraising event.

The proposed law directly confronts the long-standing friction between the SEC and the CFTC over who regulates the crypto space. By delineating clear authority, the bill aims to eliminate regulatory arbitrage and provide a more predictable legal landscape for businesses and investors.

A key update in the latest discussion draft addresses the tokenization of traditional assets, a growing area of financial innovation. The text explicitly states that an instrument "shall not cease to be a security" merely because it is issued or transferred using distributed ledger technology. This provision is designed to close potential loopholes and ensure that tokenized securities remain firmly under the purview of existing securities laws and SEC oversight.

To balance regulation with growth, the bill includes several pro-innovation measures. It proposes liability protections for software developers and establishes a joint "CFTC-SEC Micro-Innovation Sandbox," which would allow companies to test novel products in a controlled regulatory environment before a full-scale market launch. The legislation also includes provisions for the regulation of payment stablecoins.

For the crypto industry, the implications are significant. Market participants believe the regulatory clarity offered by the bill, if passed, could unlock a wave of institutional investment that has remained on the sidelines due to legal ambiguity. Furthermore, mandated disclosure requirements for the originators of "ancillary assets" aim to enhance investor protection by providing greater transparency.

While the bill is still in a discussion phase and faces a lengthy legislative process before becoming law, its introduction marks a pivotal moment. It signals a concerted effort by lawmakers to move beyond patchwork regulation and create a durable framework for the future of digital finance in the United States.

Blockpass is the gold standard for regulatory compliant onboarding processes for your crypto investments. Discover how Blockpass can optimize your crypto KYC & AML onboarding procedures, bolster security, and cultivate user confidence. For further details, please schedule a call, submit a message, or get started setting up your service.

Sources: Responsible Financial Innovation Act of 2025